“When building a machine as large and as complex as ITER, difficulties and setbacks do not come as surprises - they are an integral part of manufacturing, assembling and installing first-of-a-kind components,” the ITER Organisation said recently.
The International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor (ITER), under construction in Saint-Paul-lès-Durance in southern France, is a first-of-a-kind global collaboration. Construction of ITER is funded mainly by the European Union (45.6%) with the remainder shared equally by China, India, Japan, Korea, Russia and the USA (9.1% each). However, in practice, the members deliver little monetary contribution to the project, instead providing ‘in-kind’ contributions of components, systems or buildings.
ITER noted: “From the first stages of fabrication to the final insertion in the Tokamak pit, component challenges are a constant and familiar companion. Sometimes, however, in the midst of ordinary, almost daily issues, a concern of a larger dimension arises - one which demands in-depth examination, creativity in devising corrective actions, and time and budget to repair. Two-and-a-half years into its machine assembly phase, ITER is facing a concern of this nature: defects have been identified in two key tokamak components, the thermal shields and the vacuum vessel sectors.”
The vacuum vessel thermal shields and the cryostat thermal shields are actively cooled silver-plated elements, 20 and 10 millimetres thick respectively, that contribute to thermally insulating the superconducting magnet system operating at 4K, or minus 269 °C. In each of the nine vacuum vessel modules - one of which is already installed in the machine assembly pit—thermal shield panels are positioned in the narrow gap between the vacuum vessel sector and the two associated toroidal field coils. A circular thermal shield, approximately 20 metres in diameter, also lines the inner wall of the cryostat to complete the heat barrier protecting the superconducting magnetic system. The lower section of the cryostat thermal shield was positioned inside the pit in January 2021.
“In November 2021, helium tests detected leaks on an element of the vacuum vessel thermal shield that had been delivered a year and a half earlier,” ITER said. “Working groups with experts from different ITER partners were rapidly established to investigate, and they were able to identify the root cause for the leaks - stress caused by the bending and welding of the cooling fluid pipes to the thermal shield panels, compounded by a slow chemical reaction due to the presence of chlorine residues in some small areas near the pipe welds. This reaction had generated what is called ‘stress corrosion cracking’ and, over time, cracks up to 2.2 millimetres deep had developed in the pipes. Investigative techniques (high-resolution CT scanning, scanning electron microscope, energy-dispersive X-ray spectrometer, and metallographic observation) revealed cracks in thermal shield cooling pipes
"The risk is too high, and the consequences of a leaking thermal shield panel during operation are too dire. We must assume the problem is extensive," said ITER Director-General Pietro Barabaschi. "Dealing with it in the pit on the module that has already been assembled would be enormously difficult. This means we have to lift out the installed module and disassemble it in order to proceed with the repairs. We are exploring different possibilities, from on-site repair to re-manufacturing in an outside facility, possibly with different pipe attachment options. But there is no question about the need to replace the cooling pipes."
Whereas this thermal shield issue is now thought to be essentially due to a weakness in the design of the cooling pipe attachment, which made it impossible to fully wash away the chloride residue, vacuum vessel sector issues stem from a more common industrial fabrication difficulty: the distortion that invariably occurs in welding processes, compounded by the overall complexity of the ITER vacuum vessel sectors. A total of approximately 23 kilometres of piping are welded to the surface of the thermal shield panels.
ITER noted that, as in many complex technological objects, fabrication is based on tri-dimensional computer-assisted blueprints. “In the ideal world of 3D design, a component's dimensions are by definition nominal and parts fit together like cogs and gears in a pricey wristwatch. In the real world of industry however, things are different: deviations during the manufacturing process are inevitable and may lead to "non-conformities" that need to be addressed. ITER, like any industrial venture, deals with such matters on a daily basis.”
Deviations during the welding process of the vacuum vessel sectors led to dimensional ''non-conformities'' on the outer shells, affecting the geometry of the field joints where the sectors are to be welded together. “When a finalised component is made of several sections individually machined and welded together, and when it is as tall as a six-storey building like the ITER vacuum vessel, dimensional non-conformities are on par with the component's size.”
In the case of the three vacuum vessel sectors that have already been delivered, the welding of the component's four individual segments caused deviations from nominal dimensions that were more substantial than the specified limit in different locations on the component's outer shell. “These dimensional non-conformities modified the geometry of the field joints where the sectors are to be welded together, thus compromising the access and operation of the bespoke automated welding tools,” ITER said.
Despite ongoing coactivity in the assembly pit's restricted space and particle contamination risks, solutions were initially contemplated to execute repairs in situ, without extracting the vacuum vessel module from its present position. "The thermal shield issue has now changed the perspective," said Barabaschi. "As we need to disassemble the module to fix the thermal shield piping, the question of whether or not to repair the vacuum vessel sector in the pit becomes irrelevant. We have no other solution but to remove it."
As repair strategies for both components are being refined, schedule scenarios established, and costs estimated, the present sequence of vacuum vessel assembly is now on hold. "We know what we need to do, we know ways to do it, and we are of course very much aware of the consequences as far as schedule and cost are concerned - and they will not be insignificant." In order to deal efficiently with both thermal shield piping and vacuum vessel issues, the decision was taken to lift the module already installed in the machine pit and disassemble it in order to proceed with the repairs.
The consequences on schedule and cost ''will not be insignificant'' Barabaschi warned. "If there is one 'good thing' about this situation," he added, "it is that it is happening at a moment we can fix it. The knowhow we are acquiring in dealing with ITER's first-of-a-kind components will serve others when they launch their own fusion ventures. It is in ITER's nature and mission, as a unique and ambitious research infrastructure, to go through a whole range of challenges and setbacks during construction. And it is therefore our task and duty to promptly inform the engaged scientific community so that they will take precautions when dealing with the same type of assemblies."
Image: Part of the ITER reactor vacuum chamber in the assembly hall (courtesy of ITER)